vioblk should not accept an all-zero serial number
While I still believe
blkdev should provide device ID fabrication and in-label persistence (as
cmdk, etc, do; see #9985) for drivers that are not able to come up with a useful devid themselves, it's also true that a devid isn't strictly required. Furthermore, having more than one device in the system with the same devid presents many challenges; e.g.,
libdiskmgmt) will list at most one of the Virtio block devices in the system, because it has deduplicated them (in error) by devid.
Some basic tests demonstrate that we could at least detect obviously invalid serial numbers (say, all zeroes or all ones) and refuse to turn these into a devid. Doing so in a test environment allows
diskinfo to list all of the virtual block devices, and ZFS still appears to work (the
devid property is correctly omitted from the vdev configuration nvlist).
(Note, an all-zeroes serial number presently becomes devid
Updated by Joshua M. Clulow over 1 year ago
The current draft version of the Virtio specific version 1.1 is available at:
As of the time of writing this comment, the specification rather distressingly still omits the
VIRTIO_BLK_T_GET_ID command from its description of the the operation of the Virtio Block Device (Section 5.2).
There is evidence of an attempt in 2012 to get the command into the specification, though it's not clear why it still has not appeared. The text from that attempt (with a little cleaning up) says:
VIRTIO_BLK_T_GET_IDis issued, the device identifier, up to 20 bytes, is written to the buffer. The identifier should be interpreted as an ASCII string. It is terminated with a zero byte, unless it is exactly 20 bytes long.
Given this string is to be interpreted as ASCII, our currently handling is not sufficient: we perform the operation to read the ID using the target
char *, allowing the device to write whatever it wants. We then pass this to
ddi_devid_init() with the fixed length of 20 bytes -- even if it would have been a shorter string!
It seems appropriate instead to read the value from the device, then examine each returned byte to ensure it is printable ASCII. The string should be terminated at the first zero byte, or after 20 bytes; nonprintable characters prior to the first zero should be replaced with something printable; e.g.,
?. In the case where a serial of 20 zero bytes is returned, this will result in an empty string; an empty string cannot be used to create an ATA-style devid.
Updated by Electric Monk about 1 year ago
- Status changed from New to Closed
- % Done changed from 0 to 100
commit f8296c60994fb27105f37ac6f75661e4a6bdbab7 Author: Joshua M. Clulow <firstname.lastname@example.org> Date: 2019-08-16T17:37:47.000Z 11329 improved Virtio framework 10012 vioblk should not accept an all-zero serial number 7366 vioif happily creates rx descriptors until it consumes all memory Reviewed by: Robert Mustacchi <email@example.com> Approved by: Richard Lowe <firstname.lastname@example.org>