Feature #8423


Implement large_dnode pool feature

Added by Matthew Ahrens almost 4 years ago. Updated over 2 years ago.

zfs - Zettabyte File System
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:
Gerrit CR:


8423 Implement large_dnode pool feature
8199 multi-threaded dmu_object_alloc()

ZoL issues:
Improved dnode allocation #6564
Clean up large dnode code #6262
Fix dnode_hold() freeing dnode behavior #8172
Fix dnode allocation race #6414, #6439
Partial: Raw sends must be able to decrease nlevels #6821, #6864
Remove unnecessary txg syncs from receive_object() Closes #7197

This is a port from ZFS on Linux of: and

This feature adds support for variable length dnodes. Our motivation is
to eliminate the overhead associated with using spill blocks. Spill
blocks are used to store system attribute data (i.e. file metadata) that
does not fit in the dnode's bonus buffer. By allowing a larger bonus
buffer area the use of a spill block can be avoided. Spill blocks
potentially incur an additional read I/O for every dnode in a dnode
block. As a worst case example, reading 32 dnodes from a 16k dnode block
and all of the spill blocks could issue 33 separate reads. Now suppose
those dnodes have size 1024 and therefore don't need spill blocks. Then
the worst case number of blocks read is reduced to from 33 to two--one
per dnode block. In practice spill blocks may tend to be co-located on
disk with the dnode blocks so the reduction in I/O would not be this
drastic. In a badly fragmented pool, however, the improvement could be
ZFS-on-Linux systems that make heavy use of extended attributes would
benefit from this feature. In particular, ZFS-on-Linux supports the
xattr=sa dataset property which allows file extended attribute data
to be stored in the dnode bonus buffer as an alternative to the
traditional directory-based format. Workloads such as SELinux and the
Lustre distributed filesystem often store enough xattr data to force
spill bocks when xattr=sa is in effect. Large dnodes may therefore
provide a performance benefit to such systems.
Other use cases that may benefit from this feature include files with
large ACLs and symbolic links with long target names. Furthermore,
this feature may be desirable on other platforms in case future
applications or features are developed that could make use of a
larger bonus buffer area.
The size of a dnode may be a multiple of 512 bytes up to the size of
a dnode block (currently 16384 bytes). A dn_extra_slots field was
added to the current on-disk dnode_phys_t structure to describe the
size of the physical dnode on disk. The 8 bits for this field were
taken from the zero filled dn_pad2 field. The field represents how
many "extra" dnode_phys_t slots a dnode consumes in its dnode block.
This convention results in a value of 0 for 512 byte dnodes which
preserves on-disk format compatibility with older software.
Similarly, the in-memory dnode_t structure has a new dn_num_slots field
to represent the total number of dnode_phys_t slots consumed on disk.
Thus dn->dn_num_slots is 1 greater than the corresponding
dnp->dn_extra_slots. This difference in convention was adopted
because, unlike on-disk structures, backward compatibility is not a
concern for in-memory objects, so we used a more natural way to
represent size for a dnode_t.
The default size for newly created dnodes is determined by the value of
a new "dnodesize" dataset property. By default the property is set to
"legacy" which is compatible with older software. Setting the property
to "auto" will allow the filesystem to choose the most suitable dnode
size. Currently this just sets the default dnode size to 1k, but future
code improvements could dynamically choose a size based on observed
workload patterns. Dnodes of varying sizes can coexist within the same
dataset and even within the same dnode block. For example, to enable
automatically-sized dnodes, run
  1. zfs set dnodesize=auto tank/fish
The user can also specify literal values for the dnodesize property.
These are currently limited to powers of two from 1k to 16k. The
power-of-2 limitation is only for simplicity of the user interface.
Internally the implementation can handle any multiple of 512 up to 16k,
and consumers of the DMU API can specify any legal dnode value.
The size of a new dnode is determined at object allocation time and
stored as a new field in the znode in-memory structure. New DMU
interfaces are added to allow the consumer to specify the dnode size
that a newly allocated object should use. Existing interfaces are
unchanged to avoid having to update every call site and to preserve
compatibility with external consumers such as Lustre. The new
interfaces names are given below. The versions of these functions that
don't take a dnodesize parameter now just call the _dnsize() versions
with a dnodesize of 0, which means use the legacy dnode size.
New DMU interfaces:
New ZAP interfaces:
The constant DN_MAX_BONUSLEN is renamed to DN_OLD_MAX_BONUSLEN. The
spa_maxdnodesize() function should be used to determine the maximum
bonus length for a pool.
These are a few noteworthy changes to key functions:
  • The prototype for dnode_hold_impl() now takes a "slots" parameter.
    When the DNODE_MUST_BE_FREE flag is set, this parameter is used to
    ensure the hole at the specified object offset is large enough to
    hold the dnode being created. The slots parameter is also used
    to ensure a dnode does not span multiple dnode blocks. In both of
    these cases, if a failure occurs, ENOSPC is returned. Keep in mind,
    these failure cases are only possible when using DNODE_MUST_BE_FREE.

    If the DNODE_MUST_BE_ALLOCATED flag is set, "slots" must be 0.
    dnode_hold_impl() will check if the requested dnode is already
    consumed as an extra dnode slot by an large dnode, in which case
    it returns ENOENT.

  • The function dmu_object_alloc() advances to the next dnode block
    if dnode_hold_impl() returns an error for a requested object.
    This is because the beginning of the next dnode block is the only
    location it can safely assume to either be a hole or a valid
    starting point for a dnode.
  • dnode_next_offset_level() and other functions that iterate
    through dnode blocks may no longer use a simple array indexing
    scheme. These now use the current dnode's dn_num_slots field to
    advance to the next dnode in the block. This is to ensure we
    properly skip the current dnode's bonus area and don't interpret it
    as a valid dnode.
The zdb command was updated to display a dnode's size under the
"dnsize" column when the object is dumped.
For ZIL create log records, zdb will now display the slot count for
the object.
Ztest chooses a random dnodesize for every newly created object. The
random distribution is more heavily weighted toward small dnodes to
better simulate real-world datasets.
Unused bonus buffer space is filled with non-zero values computed from
the object number, dataset id, offset, and generation number. This
helps ensure that the dnode traversal code properly skips the interior
regions of large dnodes, and that these interior regions are not
overwritten by data belonging to other dnodes. A new test visits each
object in a dataset. It verifies that the actual dnode size matches what
was stored in the ztest block tag when it was created. It also verifies
that the unused bonus buffer space is filled with the expected data
ZFS Test Suite
Added six new large dnode-specific tests, and integrated the dnodesize
property into existing tests for zfs allow and send/recv.
ZFS send streams for datasets containing large dnodes cannot be received
on pools that don't support the large_dnode feature. A send stream with
large dnodes sets a DMU_BACKUP_FEATURE_LARGE_DNODE flag which will be
unrecognized by an incompatible receiving pool so that the zfs receive
will fail gracefully.
While not implemented here, it may be possible to generate a
backward-compatible send stream from a dataset containing large
dnodes. The implementation may be tricky, however, because the send
object record for a large dnode would need to be resized to a 512
byte dnode, possibly kicking in a spill block in the process. This
means we would need to construct a new SA layout and possibly
register it in the SA layout object. The SA layout is normally just
sent as an ordinary object record. But if we are constructing new
layouts while generating the send stream we'd have to build the SA
layout object dynamically and send it at the end of the stream.
For sending and receiving between pools that do support large dnodes,
the drr_object send record type is extended with a new field to store
the dnode slot count. This field was repurposed from unused padding
in the structure.
ZIL Replay
The dnode slot count is stored in the uppermost 8 bits of the lr_foid
field. The bits were unused as the object id is currently capped at
48 bits.
Resizing Dnodes
It should be possible to resize a dnode when it is dirtied if the
current dnodesize dataset property differs from the dnode's size, but
this functionality is not currently implemented. Clearly a dnode can
only grow if there are sufficient contiguous unused slots in the
dnode block, but it should always be possible to shrink a dnode.
Growing dnodes may be useful to reduce fragmentation in a pool with
many spill blocks in use. Shrinking dnodes may be useful to allow
sending a dataset to a pool that doesn't support the large_dnode
Feature Reference Counting
The reference count for the large_dnode pool feature tracks the
number of datasets that have ever contained a dnode of size larger
than 512 bytes. The first time a large dnode is created in a dataset
the dataset is converted to an extensible dataset. This is a one-way
operation and the only way to decrement the feature count is to
destroy the dataset, even if the dataset no longer contains any large
dnodes. The complexity of reference counting on a per-dnode basis was
too high, so we chose to track it on a per-dataset basis similarly to
the large_block feature.

Related issues

Related to illumos gate - Feature #7432: Large dnode pool featureClosedPrashanth Sreenivasa2016-09-28

Related to illumos gate - Bug #11942: Panic on zil/slog replay when TX_REMOVE followed by TX_CREATEClosedAndy Fiddaman

Actions #1

Updated by Ezomori Nozomu almost 4 years ago

Actions #2

Updated by Toomas Soome over 2 years ago

  • Description updated (diff)
Actions #3

Updated by Toomas Soome over 2 years ago

  • Tracker changed from Bug to Feature
  • Description updated (diff)
  • Assignee changed from Matthew Ahrens to Toomas Soome
  • % Done changed from 0 to 90
  • Difficulty changed from Medium to Hard
  • Tags deleted (needs-triage)
Actions #4

Updated by Jerry Jelinek over 2 years ago

Here is a list of ZoL commits we pulled in to this fix.

commit 78e21394679ed7435f9b0d10a56ce4f679c680fe
Author: Brian Behlendorf <>
Date: Wed Dec 5 09:29:33 2018 -0800
Fix dnode_hold() freeing dnode behavior
closes PR 8172

commit 047116ac76526d869e3f347afb5d81cc2b156fdf
Author: Tom Caputi <>
Date: Fri Jan 19 04:19:47 2018 -0500
Raw sends must be able to decrease nlevels
closes 6821 & 6864

commit e0dd0a32a8c8db725be673153b09bee0ca9adcf2
Author: Brian Behlendorf <>
Date: Thu Sep 7 09:48:26 2017 -0700
Revert "Handle new dnode size in incremental..."
closes PR 6576

commit 4c5b89f59e4e5c8f5b4680040118ebde09598bbe
Author: Olaf Faaland <>
Date: Tue Sep 5 16:15:04 2017 -0700
Improved dnode allocation and dmu_hold_impl()
closes PR 6564

commit 73aac4aa410121ddcc08bd7fd15d987caf101584
Author: Ned Bass <>
Date: Tue Jul 25 18:52:40 2017 -0700
Some additional send stream validity checking
closes PR 6396

commit 817b1b6e7b6f9b8890a550c7c7efabdba41dd352
Author: Matthew Ahrens <>
Date: Thu Jun 29 10:18:03 2017 -0700
Clean up large dnode code
Resolves issues discovered when porting to OpenZFS.

commit 08f0510d87186575db00269fff17a3409de5ceb6
Author: LOLi <>
Date: Sat Jan 14 00:47:34 2017 +0100
Fix unallocated object detection for large_dnode datasets

commit 50c957f702ea6d08a634e42f73e8a49931dd8055
Author: Ned Bass <>
Date: Wed Mar 16 18:25:34 2016 -0700
Implement large_dnode pool feature

Actions #5

Updated by Electric Monk over 2 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Closed
  • % Done changed from 90 to 100

git commit 54811da5ac6b517992fdc173df5d605e4e61fdc0

commit  54811da5ac6b517992fdc173df5d605e4e61fdc0
Author: Toomas Soome <>
Date:   2019-02-13T16:42:18.000Z

    8423 Implement large_dnode pool feature
    8199 multi-threaded dmu_object_alloc()
    7432 Large dnode pool feature
    Reviewed by: Jerry Jelinek <>
    Reviewed by: Jason King <>
    Approved by: Dan McDonald <>

Actions #6

Updated by Andy Fiddaman over 1 year ago

  • Related to Bug #11942: Panic on zil/slog replay when TX_REMOVE followed by TX_CREATE added

Also available in: Atom PDF